Tattoo Goo vs Hustle Butter: Which Aftercare Balm to Stock

Short answer
Is Tattoo Goo or Hustle Butter better?
Neither is better across the board; they do different jobs. Tattoo Goo is an olive oil and beeswax balm in a 0.75 oz tin that its maker sells for healing and healed tattoos. Hustle Butter Deluxe is a vegan shea butter balm in 1 and 5 oz tubs that its maker sells as an in-session glide and as aftercare. Stock Goo as a cheap take-home, Hustle Butter for the station and vegan clients.
Key takeaways
- Both makers describe their balms as petroleum free; Tattoo Goo also says its balm is lanolin free.
- Tattoo Goo's balm contains beeswax and lavender oil, so it is not vegan; Hustle Butter describes Deluxe as vegan.
- Only Hustle Butter tells artists to use its balm during the session as a glide; Tattoo Goo's directions cover healing and healed tattoos.
- Hustle Butter Deluxe lists fragrance and fragrance components; the brand sells a separate Fragrance-Free Tattoo Balm.
- At Miami Tattoo Supplies at the time of writing (November 2026), the Tattoo Goo tin costs $4.99 to $7.99 and Hustle Butter Deluxe $15 to $24.
On this page 7 sections
Clients ask for both by name, and a studio rarely needs to stock both for the same job. The useful comparison is not which one "heals better", which neither maker can show you on a label, but what is in each, how each maker tells you to use it, and what it costs per client. This page is published by Miami Tattoo Supplies, which sells both in its tattoo aftercare collection. Everything below comes from the makers' own product pages and the store's prices at the time of writing (November 2026). It is general information, not medical advice.
How do Tattoo Goo and Hustle Butter differ?
They differ in base, in intended use and in size. Tattoo Goo is a firm balm built on olive oil and beeswax, sold in a small tin for the client to heal with. Hustle Butter Deluxe is a softer shea butter and plant-oil balm sold in tubs, and its maker pitches it for the artist's station as well as the client's bag.
| Tattoo Goo Tattoo Balm | Hustle Butter Deluxe | |
|---|---|---|
| Base (first listed) | Olive fruit oil, beeswax, cocoa seed butter | Shea butter, sunflower seed oil, caprylic/capric triglyceride |
| Maker's stated use | Healing and healed tattoos, 2–3 times daily | In-session glide; aftercare through healing; daily care after |
| Petroleum / lanolin | Petroleum free, lanolin free | Petroleum free |
| Vegan | No (contains beeswax) | Yes, per the maker |
| Fragrance | Lavender oil; colorant D&C Green 6 | Fragrance plus listed components |
| Size | 0.75 oz tin | 1 fl oz or 5 fl oz tub; cases of 24 |
| Price at MTS (Nov 2026) | $4.99–$7.99 | $15–$24 |
What is in each balm?
Read the full lists before you hand either one to a client with sensitive skin. These are the ingredients each maker publishes.
Tattoo Goo Tattoo Balm: olive fruit oil, beeswax, cocoa seed butter, wheat germ oil, tocopheryl acetate (vitamin E), lavender oil, sunflower seed oil, rosemary leaf extract and the colorant D&C Green 6. The maker says the balm contains over 60% olive oil and describes all its products as petroleum jelly and lanolin free, dermatologist tested and cruelty free.
Hustle Butter Deluxe: shea butter, sunflower seed oil, caprylic/capric triglyceride, hydrogenated coconut oil, aloe leaf extract, tocopheryl acetate, mango seed butter, fragrance, safflower seed oil, rice bran oil, green tea leaf extract and rosemary leaf extract, followed by the fragrance components benzyl benzoate, citronellol, coumarin, geraniol, hexyl cinnamal and hydroxycitronellal. The maker describes it as petroleum free, vegan, cruelty free, paraben and phthalate free, dermatologist tested and hypoallergenic.
Three practical differences follow from those lists:
- Vegan clients: Tattoo Goo contains beeswax. Hustle Butter is the one to offer; the wider question is covered in is tattoo ink vegan.
- Scent sensitivity: Both contain scent ingredients. Hustle Butter Deluxe carries added fragrance; Tattoo Goo carries lavender oil. Hustle Butter also sells a separate Fragrance-Free Tattoo Balm, which is the one to suggest to a client who reacts to scent.
- Wheat allergy: Tattoo Goo lists wheat germ oil.
Can you tattoo with Tattoo Goo or Hustle Butter?
Only Hustle Butter is sold for that. Its directions tell artists to use Deluxe during sessions as an in-process glide, applying a small amount and reapplying as needed, and tell collectors to use it as aftercare through healing. The maker says its petroleum-free formula leaves no buildup and does not interfere with stencils. Tattoo Goo's directions are to apply the balm to healing or healed tattoos two to three times a day; it is not presented as a glide.
If you want one product on the tray and in the client's bag, that points to Hustle Butter. If you already use a separate glide, the comparison is only about aftercare. Our tattoo glide and butter guide compares the in-session options, including petrolatum jars and other butters.
Which costs less per client?
Tattoo Goo, by a wide margin, if the client takes the product home. A sealed tin at $4.99 to $7.99 at the time of writing is cheap enough to include with every tattoo, and a 0.75 oz tin is sized for one person's healing.
Hustle Butter makes more sense as a station product, where one 5 oz tub covers many sessions, or as a retail item for clients who ask for it. At Miami Tattoo Supplies the Hustle Butter Deluxe balm is $15 for 1 oz and $24 for 5 oz, with cases of 24 at $230 (1 oz) and $399 (5 oz) for studios that send every client home with a tub. The Tattoo Goo Original tin is in the same aftercare collection.
Which one should a studio stock?
Pick by how you work, not by brand loyalty:
- One product for glide and aftercare, vegan clients, a retail line at the counter: Hustle Butter Deluxe, with the Fragrance-Free version for sensitive clients.
- A low-cost sealed take-home for every client, separate glide at the station: Tattoo Goo tins.
- Neither suits the client: a fragrance-free lotion such as After Inked, or Recovery's tattoo salve tin.
Whichever you choose, name it in your written aftercare instructions so the client uses what you planned for; a starting template is in tattoo aftercare instructions for clients. Full brand detail is in our guides to Tattoo Goo and Hustle Butter.
What do dermatologists say about balms like these?
The American Academy of Dermatology recommends a water-based lotion or cream on dry tattooed skin and says petroleum-based products such as petroleum jelly can cause the ink to fade. Both balms here are petroleum free, but both are oil-based balms rather than water-based lotions. Keep layers thin either way, and follow the artist's instructions first.
Gear mentioned
Products from the Miami Tattoo Supplies catalog, the publisher of this site. Check current price and stock on the store.

Hustle Butter
Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Balm
View at Miami Tattoo Supplies: Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Balm
Tattoo Goo Original Single After Care Tins
View at Miami Tattoo Supplies: Tattoo Goo Original Single After Care Tins
Hustle Butter
Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Balm 1oz - Case of 24
View at Miami Tattoo Supplies: Hustle Butter Deluxe Tattoo Balm 1oz - Case of 24
Recovery
Recovery Tattoo Salve - 0.75oz Tins
View at Miami Tattoo Supplies: Recovery Tattoo Salve - 0.75oz Tins
After Inked
After Inked Tattoo Aftercare Moisturizer Lotion 3oz Tube
View at Miami Tattoo Supplies: After Inked Tattoo Aftercare Moisturizer Lotion 3oz Tube
Frequently asked questions
Is Tattoo Goo or Hustle Butter better for a new tattoo?
Neither maker publishes evidence that one heals better. They differ in ingredients and use: Tattoo Goo is an olive oil and beeswax balm sold for healing and healed tattoos, while Hustle Butter Deluxe is a vegan shea balm also sold as a glide. Use the one your artist recommends, and switch if your skin reacts.
Does Tattoo Goo have petroleum in it?
No, according to the maker. Tattoo Goo describes all its products as petroleum jelly and lanolin free. The balm's published ingredients are olive fruit oil, beeswax, cocoa seed butter, wheat germ oil, vitamin E, lavender oil, sunflower seed oil, rosemary leaf extract and a green colorant.
Is Hustle Butter vegan and Tattoo Goo not?
Yes. Hustle Butter describes Deluxe as vegan and cruelty free. Tattoo Goo says its products are cruelty free, but the balm's ingredient list includes beeswax, so it is not vegan. For a vegan client, Hustle Butter or a vegan lotion such as After Inked is the simpler choice.
Can Tattoo Goo be used as a tattoo glide?
Tattoo Goo does not sell its balm for that. Its directions are to apply it to healing or healed tattoos two to three times a day. If you want a balm made for use during the session, Hustle Butter Deluxe is sold as an in-process glide, or use a dedicated glide product.
How much do Tattoo Goo and Hustle Butter cost?
At Miami Tattoo Supplies at the time of writing (November 2026), the Tattoo Goo Original tin is $4.99 to $7.99, Hustle Butter Deluxe is $15 for 1 oz and $24 for 5 oz, and Hustle Butter cases of 24 are $230 and $399. Prices change, so check the store before ordering.